May 8th, 2009 by Alexandra
Mark it down, May 7th at 6:34pm, I received my first Ask Alex relationship question. Considering how tiny this is in the grand scope of things I shouldn’t be so excited. But I am. Let’s move on…
Rachel asks:
“My boyfriend has this ex. They were together for 3 1/2 years before he met me and she treated him like dirt when they broke up. He’s the nicest guy and I think she used him. She moved away and now is back in town. She sent him an email asking if they could hang-out. I think that sux. He told me he wouldn’t go if I didn’t want him to. I don’t want him around her, but should I tell him to go anyway?”
For starters Rachel, based on the fact that you had the foresight, the vision if you will, to send in the first ever Ask Alex question, I’m guessing you’re a smoking hot MENSA candidate. Just sayin’.
And the answer is 100% yes.
I think it’s great that he’s been honest with you; seemingly about the relationship itself (though always remember every story has two sides) and that his ex has made some attempt to re-enter his life.
Let’s see… woman has a messy break-up, leaves town, has some unsuccessful relationships, returns to town looking to rekindle romance with a love lost. That’s a typical Hollywood tale isn’t it? Normally I am not a fan of any contrived Hollywood vision of girl + boy (see …stop going to romantic comedies), but in this case I believe it to be plausible.
There is the slightest chance that she wants to see your boyfriend only to make amends. Maybe she’s had some revelation about her behavior and wants to apologize. And maybe she wants to wear a dress with a v cut down to her navel and packing a fresh new birth control subscription. Sadly I think the latter is more likely.
We always tend to romanticize past relationships. The further you get from the reality, you remove the bad times from your foremost thoughts. The disagreements and negative feelings that lead to the break-up in the first place are pushed aside for a focus on the good times. Before you know it, the Miller Lite swigging, cursing, crotch scratching ex transforms into Danny Ocean.
So how does any of this rambling relate to the question?
Your boyfriend, however honest and well intentioned, clearly wants to go. If he didn’t, he would have deleted that email/voicemail from her and never brought it up. If he has any lingering thought or question it needs to be answered or it will only grow in his mind. Best that bubble, whatever memories of their times together he has created in his mind, burst. Burst or float – you have no control over which and you can’t live in fear of it floating.
If it’s really over between the two of them, he’ll know it within 5 minutes of sitting down with her. He won’t have the same tingle when he sees her enter the restaurant. Sparks won’t fly when their eyes meet. His thoughts will immediately go back to you and he’ll feel like a moron.
On the other hand, what if sparks do fly and you lose him? If that happens, your relationship wasn’t meant to live happily ever after. But you will rest comfortably with the knowledge that you are no one’s consolation prize.